Odvetniška družba Neffat in partnerji o.p., d.o.o.
Miklošičeva cesta 18, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenija
- Telefon: 01/300-00-70
- e-pošta: info@neffat.si

22.11.2024
In early August 2024 the Guardian reported an article about how Argentina will use AI to "predict future crimes" and in it stated as follows:
»The country's far-right president Javier Milei this week created the Artificial Intelligence Applied to Security Unit, which the legislation says will use "machine-learning algorithms to analyse historical crime data to predict future crimes". It is also expected to deploy facial recognition software to identify "wanted persons", patrol social media, and analyse real-time security camera footage to detect suspicious activities.«1
In general, politicians like to make big promises that are mostly unrealized and quickly forgotten because of other events or because they are too ambitious for the time being. With that in mind, for the purposes of this article we will not focus on the promised technology of crime prediction, but on the idea of using facial recognition software to identify so-called wanted persons in a real-time analysis of security camera footage in the European Union (EU).
First, let's take a step back and see if we already have access to the facial recognition technology and the hardware ecosystem to stream the real-time data to it.
Facial recognition technology is nothing new and has been around in one form or another since the 1960s. It wasn't until the 2000's that the public began to become more aware of its use, such as at Super Bowl XXXV in 2001, Facebook's DeepFace photo-tagging software in 2014, as a security feature with Windows Hello and Android's Trusted Face in 2015, Face ID on the iPhone X in 2017, and even some vendors, including Amazon, IBM, and Microsoft, stopped selling their technology to law enforcement in response to the Black Lives Matter protests against police brutality in 2020.2
Since the announcement of the European Commission's 5G Action Plan for the European Union in 2016 3 the EU has achieved 72,00 % population 5G coverage on September 2024 with coverages of 91,00 % in Germany, 99,70% in Italy and 84,00% in France.4 Suffice it to say that there is enough coverage of civilian 5G infrastructure to provide operational real-time data feed of HD standard video quality via high-speed data transfer, and what's even more interesting is that the three major EU economies have better than average coverage, which includes one of the largest urban centers in the EU (such as Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Rome, Milan, Turin, Munich, Berlin, Stuttgart, Hamburg,...). So there's no doubt that we have facial recognition technology (even in civilian use) and EU has the hardware ecosystem to stream the real-time data to it via 5G network coverage.
Before we can start the search, we need to capture the visual data of the people we are looking for using facial recognition technology through video feeds provided by the 5G network. The EU has several databases that store visual characteristics of individuals, one of which is EURODAC (European Asylum Dactyloscopy Database), which checks an asylum application by comparing fingerprint records. But normally these databases are not open to the public (rightly so) and store data that is visual but not useful for our purpose of facial recognition. But there is already a publicly available database of internationally wanted persons that contains visual photo information about the individuals that can be used to locate them using facial recognition technology, and it is already standardized and available. That database is INTERPOL's Red Notice. Red Notice is described by INTERPOL:
» A Red Notice is a request to law enforcement worldwide to locate and provisionally arrest a person pending extradition, surrender, or similar legal action. It is based on an arrest warrant or court order issued by the judicial authorities in the requesting country. «5
Having established that we have the software, a 5G network that can handle HD video stream input and an already publicly available database of images of wanted persons, let's see if we also have the legal framework that could be the basis for using facial recognition software to identify wanted persons in a real-time analysis of security camera footage in the EU.
Our scenario is that we have a real-time security camera footage feed of a public place attached to a public building and the controller is a public authority or agency, let say a security camera of the Parliament building in the center of Ljubljana, Slovenia. According to Article 4(7) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), the police security service that manages the camera is the controller because it is a public authority. There is no doubt that in our case the controller has the lawfulness of processing, in fact we could say that it has it based on three paragraphs of Article 6 of GDPR and these are:
(c) processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the controller is subject;
(d) processing is necessary in order to protect the vital interests of the data subject or of another natural person and
(e) processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller.
Now the question arises whether the controller (in our case, the public authority) has the necessary legal leverage to use the facial recognition software to identify a subject from the INTERPOL Red Notice wanted list in real-time video feed? According to Article 35(1) of the GDPR, the controller has to carry out a data protection impact assessment, in particular when using new technologies and taking into account the nature, scope, context and purposes of the processing, it is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons. In doing so, the controller must seek the advice of the Data Protection Officer pursuant to Article 35(2) of the GDPR, and pursuant to Article 35(3)(c) of the GDPR, this is required in particular in the case of systematic monitoring of a publicly accessible area on a large scale. The assessment must take into account the principles relating to the processing of personal data required by Article 5 of the GDPR, in particular by the point c) of the paragraph 1, which requires that the personal data must be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which they are processed ("data minimisation').
In addition, usually EU member states have their Lex Specialis on the subject of personal data protection in Slovenia, this is the Personal Data Protection Act (ZVOP-2), which specifically addresses public video surveillance in Article 80, which puts a hard ban on the use of biometric personal data for facial recognition technology, as it states in paragraph 10 as follows:
» (10) Automatic number plate recognition systems and systems that process biometric personal data are prohibited in public areas. «
Wait, it gets worse, as Article 20 of the GDPR prohibits combining or linking biometric personal data with other databases, unless provided for by another law or with the consent of the data subject.6
But isn't ZVOP-2 another law (Lex Specialis)? Yes, it is indeed, and we already have the Information Commissioner's opinion on our subject, entitled Application for biometric measures:
»Article 82 of the ZVOP-2 provides that the processing of biometric personal data in the public sector may only be provided for by law if it is strictly necessary for the security of persons, the security of property or the protection of classified information, for the identification of missing or deceased individuals or for the protection of business secrets, and if these purposes cannot be achieved by less restrictive means. «7
If you have a keen eye, you will rightly say, but we have a prohibition on processing biometric personal data in public areas, and processing biometric personal data in the public sector is not the same thing, so our camera on the parliament building is no go. You would be right, but there is another exception in paragraph 5 of Article 82 of ZVOP-2 that stands:
» (5) In the public sector, the processing of biometric personal data relating to the entry into a building or parts of a building may exceptionally be introduced by another law, subject to the reasonable application of Article 83 (4), (5) and (6) of this Act, if it is strictly necessary for the safety of persons, the security of property, the protection of classified information or business secrets. «
Not all wanted persons represent a risk for the safety of persons, the security of property, the protection of classified information or business secrets, and even if they do, it is very hard to make a case that we are justified in searching them for a longer period of time on all cameras at all entrances to all public buildings or parts of buildings (let's extend our search from just the Slovenian Parliament building).
For such a search we would need a global event that threatens the security in the whole EU and it would help that we already have some kind of Lex Specialis and EU directive.
DIRECTIVE (EU) 2015/849 on the prevention of the use of the financial system for the purposes of money laundering or terrorist financing, amending Regulation (EU) No. 648/2012 (MLT) and the Slovenian Act on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (ZPPDFT-2) are these acts. MLT is clear in its 1 sentence of paragraph 4 of the introduction:
»Money laundering and terrorist financing are frequently carried out in an international context. Measures adopted solely at national or even at Union level, without taking into account international coordination and cooperation, would have very limited effect. «
Conclusion:
In the opinion of this author, even in our current EU legal framework, there is a possibility of using facial recognition software to identify wanted persons in real time with security camera footage of public buildings, as long as these wanted persons represent a security risk in the areas of money laundering and terrorist financing in an international context.
This is for now, but who knows what the future will bring and what kind of new EU directives or new local lex specialis laws will be enacted.
It is hard to ignore how life imitates art. Video cameras are our digital eyes, no doubt, but they are eyes without a face. In 1983, Billy Idol and Steve Stevens made a song called Eyes Without a Face in which they state that eyes without a face have no human grace. At the time of writing, the author of this article confesses that he has not checked all the codes of the facial recognition software, but he is quite sure that programming lines of grace are not in it. What is even more fascinating is that the inspiration for the 1983's song was a French film Les yeux sans visage (Eyes Without a Face) directed by Georges Franju in 1960, inspired by the novel of the same title written by Jean Redon in 1959. The story is about a plastic surgeon who tries to reconstruct his daughter's face, which was disfigured by an accident. In the end, due to so many medical precautions, his daughter completely loses any tissue of here original face, only her eyes remain.
In the opinion of this author, the future directives and laws will still use and regulate our digital eyes, but let's hope we won't lose our face.
For detailed legal advice tailored to your specific circumstances, our law firm's expertise in public procurement, construction and environmental law is at your disposal. Contact us via our website or send an enquiry to info@neffat.si.
Pripravil:
Marko Čabraja
Odvetnik
1 https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/01/argentina-ai-predicting-future-crimes-citizen-rights
2 https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/how-facial-recognition-works/
3 https://5gobservatory.eu/category/5g-action-plan/
4 https://5gobservatory.eu/observatory-overview/eu-scoreboard/#
5 https://www.interpol.int/How-we-work/Notices/Red-Notices
6 https://www.ip-rs.si/varstvo-osebnih-podatkov/obveznosti-upravljavcev/prijava-biometrijskih-ukrepov/
7 https://www.ip-rs.si/en/data-protection/obligations-of-data-processors/application-for-biometric-measures
8 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0053459/
Odvetniška družba Neffat in partnerji o.p., d.o.o.
Miklošičeva cesta 18, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenija
Avtorji: Spletna Postaja
Spletna stran uporablja piškotke za boljše delovanje
Z brskanjem po naši spletni strani se strinjate, da lahko uporabljamo piškotke, ki so namenjeni vaši boljši uporabniški izkušnji na naši spletni strani. Za lastne potrebe analitike uporabljamo Google Analytics, ki v ta namen namesti piškotke (izbriši GA piškotke). Več o piškotkih.



